AIMCo's Severance Costs Jump 383% After Executive Purge

Alberta Investment Management Corp. paid nearly C$6 million ($4.4 million) in severance and other benefits to a departing chief investment officer who was in the job for about 20 months.
Marlene Puffer left the public money manager last September, several weeks before the provincial government stunned staff by firing the entire board, Chief Executive Officer Evan Siddall and other executives.
The severance disclosure is contained in Aimco’s new annual report, which says the firm shelled out a total of C$7.9 million in termination pay for “key management personnel” during the year, a 383% increase from the previous year.
In sacking Siddall and the board, the government accused them of allowing costs to soar as they added new international offices and increased staff. Former Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper was named Aimco’s chair and it’s currently operating under an interim CEO, Ray Gilmour.
Since the November purge, the firm has been in restructuring mode, closing offices in New York and Singapore and laying off staff. Aimco’s total operating costs were C$1.15 billion for the fiscal year ended March 31, slightly above budget.
Third-party fees of C$689 million were a bit higher than expected, and the firm had unbudgeted costs for closing those two offices, the report said. Aimco had just opened its New York location at One Vanderbilt, a top office property near Grand Central Terminal.
Aimco recently laid off around a dozen employees and decided to freeze around 25 vacant roles, Bloomberg News reported. Earlier, the firm eliminated 19 jobs, including the role responsible for the diversity, equity and inclusion program. It’s searching for a new chief investment officer.
This month, Aimco added former CIO Sandra Lau to its board.
The firm, which manages about C$180 billion of pension money and other capital, produced a 12.6% return last year in its balanced fund, missing its benchmark of 13.4%. Its total fund return was 12.3%. Those results were better than some peers in the so-called Maple Eight, including the Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement System and Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan.
Alright, let's get into it, shall we, because I'm tired of posting my thoughts on LinkedIn.
First, let's have a look at executive compensation at AIMCo for 2023 taken from that year's annual report:

As you can see, former CEO, Kevin Uebelin got a severance of almost $5M in 2021 after the famous "vol blowup" back in 2020 and kept getting paid in 2022 and 2023 almost another $4M in severance even though he didn't work there.
Former CIO, Dale MacMaster, received a severance of $4.4M in 2021 and another $2.6M in severance in 2022 and 2023 even though he didn't work there either those years.
At the time, I remember finding this arrangement weird and reading former Chair's Mark Wiseman comment in the newspaper stating this is "industry standard" irritated me.
Obviously, both Kevin and Dale had a very strong legal case and that's why they were able to extract a pound of flesh from AIMCo after leaving that organization.
The much publicized vol blowup was way overblown because the VIX went to 80 during the pandemic -- something which is a 20 sigma event -- and came back down subsequently. In fact, had AIMCo kept that vol selling program alive, they would have made money but the headline risk was too large so they shut it down fast (it wasn't perfect, that's for sure, but it certainly wasn't as bad as critics claimed).
Now, why were Kevin Uebelin and Dale MacMaster who I consider to be one of the best CIOs ever at the Maple Eight fired (forced to resign)? Because the Government of Alberta was embarrassed and voiced its displeasure and members were equally irate.
Typically at the large Canadian pension funds, it's rare a CEO gets fired, the board of directors prefers to let their contract run out and when it comes up for renewal, they do not get renewed.
That's how it works 99% of the times, no big fuss, "we thank you for your service, adios amigo".
Next, have a look at executive compensation at AIMCo for 2024 taken from that the latest annual report:

In total, that's over $6.6M for a CIO that departed the organization after only 20 months there.
"Ridiculous", "insane" were the comments people were texting me and at first glance, it's an egregious amount for the time served.
But there's obviously more to this story than meets the eye.
For Marlene Puffer to walk away with over $6M in compensation + severance after exiting the organization after less than two years, it's crystal clear to me she had a solid legal case and AIMCo had to pay her to avoid more damages.
Take note boys and girls, if you have deep pockets and a solid legal case, don't stop till you extract a pound of flesh, and in this case, that's what Marlene did.
To be fair to her, she's also at an age where finding another CIO job at a large Canadian pension fund is next to impossible so that worked in her favour too.
Whatever the case, something was amiss when she was let go and judging by her severance, she made a great case to prove her case.
Next year, we will find out what former CEO Evan Siddall and former Senior Executive Managing Director, Global Head of Private Assets and Strategic Partnerships David Scudellari are going to receive in severance and I expect it to be another hefty sum.
I knew this was coming after AIMCo was purged and the negative press is distracting and quite frankly, a morale killer.
Members aren't going to be happy, the public outcry will be loud and Alberta's Government just wants to make this all go away quietly.
Here's is what I initially wrote on LinkedIn:
Severance costs are publicly listed in all annual reports but yes, to the average Canadian making ends meet, this is ridiculous! In my opinion, all of Canada’s Maple Eight should publicly list their severances for each year going back to inception. If they want to be transparent, this shouldn’t be a big issue. Governments and members are paying attention, I can assure you of this.
Typically, in any annual report, it publicly states "if any senior exec is fired without cause, this is the amount of severance owed to them".
I didn't read this in AIMCo's annual reports which is very odd.
Anyways, I'm a stickler for transparency, real transparency, not window dressing, and if it were up to me, all Crown corporations would publicly list compensation for all employees and severance amounts doled out each year for all employees that were let go going back to inception.
The lawyers will tel me it's impossible because of non disclosure agreements (NDAs) but if you ask me there is no way of knowing if there's real meritocracy and a real commitment to diversity, equity and inclusion unless you get compensation transparency including severance packages.
Lastly, I haven't gone over compensation details at all of Canada's large and mid sized pension investment managers but it's coming in September.
I'm on record stating most of the senior execs at Canada's Maple Eight are extremely well paid and they know it which is why they fiercely guard their positions. If they get let go, slim chance they'll get another job that pays as much.
That's not conjecture, that's a fact.
It doesn't mean they aren't good pension fund managers, they all are and the long-term results prove it, it just means there's a limit to how high compensation levels can get at what are Crown corporations.
Sure, they can make a case that they deserve to be paid a lot more than other Crown corporations where government interference is rampant but up to a certain limit.
Having independent governance isn't a free pass to inflate compensation every chance you get, it's a gift and should be used very wisely and judiciously.
That's my opinion so feel free to agree or disagree with me, I don't have a monopoly of wisdom on everything related to pension funds.
As far as AIMCo, I will circle back on its 2024 Annual Report as I feel it's only fair to cover it properly in a separate comment.
If you have anything to add, feel free to email me at LKolivakis@gmail.com.
Below, Alberta finally releases results of 2023 pension survey.
Not surprisingly, only10% of Albertans supported the creation of a provincial pension, according to 2023 survey results recently released. As Sean Amato reports, the NDP says the government should have come clean and abandoned the idea months ago.
Recent comments